The Order of the Arrow is an honor society within the Boy Scouts of America that has a strong connection to Native American culture. While the organization strives to honor and celebrate indigenous traditions, it has also faced criticism and controversy over the years regarding its use of Native American culture in its ceremonies and rituals. Some members of the Native American community have raised concerns about the appropriateness and authenticity of the Order of the Arrow's practices, highlighting issues of cultural appropriation and misrepresentation.
One of the most significant issues with the Order of the Arrow's use of Native American culture is cultural appropriation. Cultural appropriation is the act of taking elements from one culture and using them inappropriately or without permission. The Order of the Arrow's incorporation of Native American dance, music, language, and clothing has been criticized by some members of the Native American community who feel that their culture is being exploited for non-native purposes.
The use of Native American symbolism in the Order of the Arrow's practices has also been a point of concern. Some members of the Native American community feel that the use of feathers, headdresses, and other symbols is inappropriate and disrespectful. These symbols hold deep spiritual and cultural significance for Native American people, and their use in non-native contexts can be seen as a form of disrespect or even a violation of sacred traditions.
In conclusion, the Order of the Arrow's connection to Native American culture is a complex and often controversial issue. While the organization strives to honor and celebrate indigenous traditions, it has also faced criticism and concerns about cultural appropriation, authenticity, symbolism, and consultation. It is important for the Order of the Arrow to continue to listen to and learn from the voices of the Native American community, and to work towards greater cultural sensitivity and understanding in its practices and rituals. Only then can the organization truly fulfill its mission of promoting brotherhood, cheerfulness, and service while respecting and honoring the cultural heritage of Native American people. To learn more about the history of Indian Culture in the Order of the Arrow, check our “Monograph on Indian Culture in the OA”
William Hartman has completed his postgraduate degree in history from Duke University in Durham, North Carolina. He has published several books and written various blogs and articles on native American cultures. Read More