MRI’s and X-rays Lie About The Cause of Back Pain
Back and Neck PainNovember 22, 2010Written by Martin Schneckenberger990 views
If you have been experiencing back pain, you have probably gone to see your primary care physician or an orthopedist. They have evaluated you and probably ordered you to get an MRI or an X-ray. That is common practice today in our current health care system. When you do the MRI or X-ray, it is usually followed up with a report that is sent to the referring doctor.
Many times the MRI or X-ray will say that there are bulging discs, facet hypertrophy, stenosis and other things. As important as those things are, it is even more important to understand whether or not they correlate with your symptoms.
If you are having lower back pain and butt pain, but the MRI says you have a disc herniation at L5-S1, it is probably not the cause of the lower back pain. The reaso
I say that is because the nerves that correspond to the L5-S1 dermatome area are located in the back of the leg and they control bladder and bowl movement. A significantly herniated L5-S1 disc would cause pain in the back of the leg and affect bowl and bladder function.
I am often asked what all of the findings mean. My answer generally is to first identify what if causing your back pain rather than reading thee MRI. While I think it is very important to get these imaging studies I place extreme attention in determining if the findings are what are really causing your problem.
For example, I have had patients whose MRI and X-rays actually show nothing, yet they are in incredible amounts of pain. So what good was the MRI in this case? By examining further and looking at a person’s posture, muscle strength, muscle length, type of work, and type of recreational activities and habits, I can better diagnose what the problems could be.
Often people’s pain originates from something that they do on a daily basis like their sleep position or the posture they assume while at work. Even though their MRI might read facet hypertrophy or stenosis, it could be one of the positions you are in daily that is making your problem worse and more painful.
This article is to help inform you that there is hope beyond just your imaging results. Even as bleak as you imaging results may be or sound, there is always something that you can change, modify or improve upon that can help you in the long run.
Even if you had a 7mm herniated disc at L4-5, a very large bulge, and had really bad numbness and tingling down the legs, you could still learn what positions to avoid, what positions to try and achieve, what stretches you can do comfortably and what strengthening exercises you could do to help provide some stability to the spine.
While MRI’s and X-rays can be very helpful, I hope you can see that you have the opportunity to seek out additional advice and education on how to help improve the situation you are already in even if your imaging studies results don’t paint such a great picture.
About the Author
Further Reading
Article
Spinal Traction Therapy: The Overlooked Approach to Back and Neck Comfort
Why is spinal traction therapy often overlooked in modern healthcare? Beyond expensive mechanical devices, gentle stretching and gravity-assisted techniques offer an alternative approach to spine comfort. Discover the science of spinal decompression, the lessons of space medicine, & why this concept deserves attention
November 4, 2026
Article
How to Maintain Proper Cervical Spine Alignment During Sleep: Choosing the Right Pillow for Neck and Shoulder Comfort?
The right pillow can make a meaningful difference in nighttime neck support and morning comfort. Discover how sleeping positions, pillow height, firmness, and different pillow designs affect cervical spine alignment, and learn practical ways to reduce unnecessary neck and shoulder strain during sleep.
November 2, 2026
Article
Cervical Traction Pillows: A New Approach to Neck Support and Sleep Comfort
Discover how innovative cervical traction-inspired pillows are changing the approach to ergonomic neck support and sleep comfort. This article explores the importance of proper pillow design, cervical alignment, supportive materials, and emerging two-zone pillow technology.
October 30, 2026
Article
Memory Foam vs Cotton Pillow: Which Is Actually Better for Neck Pain in India?
Memory foam vs cotton pillow comparison for neck pain in India. Memory foam gives firmer, contoured support but retains heat and can't be washed. Cotton is breathable, affordable, cooler but less supportive. Key insight: foam cores need a washable cotton cover for hygiene, not just styling.
September 13, 2026